MENG HAI INSIGHTS
梦海专业 | 在香港全英文的文件怎么签才有效?关于香港法律文件签名、钢印、大章、小章的分别 | 前海涉港律师-梦海
近期帮助多个委托人在香港处理经济纠纷时发现,很多内地朋友拿出的"盖章"合同居然是"无效的"——一般盖的是小章;甚至有人故意混淆,故意忽悠内地人,内地朋友接触香港公司或个人法律文件时,尤其全英文的,常会问:文件要不要签名?要不要盖公章?钢印、大章、小章、签名章到底有什么分别?尤其小章,在香港社会是日常最常见的橡皮或原子圆章,很多人把它当成内地的“公章”,但这是错误理解,小章主要是用于签收快递等用途。
香港法律文件签约核心原则:签名比印章更重要
香港与内地的法律体系存在根本差异。香港采普通法,强调"签署人的意图与授权";内地对公章的效力更为强调。在香港,不管是英文文件还是繁体中文,文件的法律效力主要取决于谁签署以及该人是否有权代表签署,而不是单纯"有没有盖章"。
1.个人文件:自然人签署(手写签名或符合法律的电子签署)即可产生效力;签名是表达"我同意这份文件内容"的意思表示。
2.公司文件:公司本身不能"签名",必须通过有权人士代表公司签署,或按法律规定的方式盖上法团印章;单纯盖一个橡皮图章(俗称小章),通常不足以单独构成公司的有效签名。
即使盖了章,如果签署人无权或没有按规定方式签立,文件仍可能对公司不产生约束力;反之,符合法定方式的授权签署,即使没有盖章,也同样有效。
一句话记住:在香港,真正让公司受约束的,是"有权人的签名";大章(法团印章)是正式但可选的工具;小章(圆章)只是辅助确认,单独盖章通常不够。
香港法律文件到底怎么签才有效?
根据《公司条例》(第622章),自2014年3月3日起,公司不再强制备存或使用法团印章(俗称"钢印"或"大章")。公司可以选择有印章,也可以选择没有。签立文件有以下两种方式:
1. 使用法团印章(Common Seal)
(1)公司可选择盖上法团印章来签立文件。
(2)印章必须是金属印章,并以可阅字样刻有公司名称(《公司条例》(第622章)124.)。
(3)盖章必须按照公司章程细则的规定进行(第127(2)条)。实务上通常会同时要求董事签名确认。
《公司條例》(第622章)124.Company may have common seal etc.
-
A company may have a common seal.
-
A company’s common seal must be a metallic seal having the company’s name engraved on it in compliance with subsection (2A) in legible form. (Amended 35 of 2018 s. 10)
-
A company’s common seal must be engraved with—
-
if the company has both an English name and a Chinese name—the English name or the Chinese name or both; or
-
if the company has only an English name or a Chinese name—the English name or the Chinese name. (Added 35 of 2018 s. 10)
-
If subsection (2) is contravened, the company, and every responsible person of the company, commit an offence, and each is liable to a fine at level 3.
-
If an officer of a company or a person on behalf of a company uses, or authorizes the use of, a seal that purports to be the company’s common seal and that contravenes subsection (2), the officer or person commits an offence and is liable to a fine at level 3.
2. 不用印章的替代方式(目前最常用)
即使公司有印章,也可以选择不用印章,改用以下签署方式,效力等同于盖上法团印章(《公司条例》(第622章)第127条):
1.只有一名董事的公司:由该董事代表公司签署即可。
2.有两名或以上董事的公司:由两名董事签署,或由"一名董事 + 公司秘书"签署。
3.文件必须清楚表明"是由该公司签立"(措词不拘),才产生等同盖章的效力。
4.常见有效写法包括:"Executed by [Company Name]""signed for and on behalf of [Company Name]""由[公司名称]签立"或在签名栏直接标明公司名称 + 签署人身份。
5.如果文件完全没有任何表明"由公司签立"的字句,即使签名符合人数要求,也可能无法直接援引第127(5)条的"等同盖章"效力。
《公司条例》(第622章)127.Execution of documents by company
-
A company may execute a document under its common seal.
-
If a company executes a document under its common seal, the seal must be affixed in accordance with the provisions of its articles.
-
A company may also execute a document—
-
in the case of a company with only one director, by having it signed by the director on the company’s behalf; or
-
in the case of a company with 2 or more directors, by having it signed on the company’s behalf by—
-
the 2 directors or any 2 of the directors; or
-
any of the directors and the company secretary of the company.
-
For the purposes of subsection (3), if a person is to sign a document on behalf of 2 or more companies, the person must sign the document separately in each capacity.
-
A document signed in accordance with subsection (3) and expressed (in whatever words) to be executed by the company has effect as if the document had been executed under the company’s common seal.
-
In favour of a person specified in subsection (7), a document is to be regarded as having been executed by a company if the document purports to have been signed in accordance with subsection (3).
-
The person is a purchaser in good faith for valuable consideration and includes—
-
a lessee;
-
a mortgagee; or
-
any other person who for valuable consideration acquires the property.
-
This section also applies to a document that is executed, or purports to be executed, by a company in the name of or on behalf of another person whether or not that other person is also a company.
3. 签立"契据"(Deed)的额外要求
如果文件是契据(例如某些不动产转让、担保、权力委托等正式文件),除了按第127条方式签立外,还必须:
1.在文件中表明"作为契据签立";
2.并作出"交付"(delivery,即承认文件对自己有约束力)。
第127条解决的是"谁签、怎么签";第128条解决的是"如何成为契据",法律依据主要是《公司条例》第127条及第128条。
《公司条例》(第622章)128.Execution of deeds by company
(1)A company may execute a document as a deed by—
(a)executing it in accordance with section 127;
(b)having it expressed (in whatever words) to be executed by the company as a deed; and
(c)delivering it as a deed.
(2)For the purposes of subsection (1)(c), a document is presumed, unless the contrary is proved, to be delivered as a deed on its being executed in accordance with section 127.
(3)If there is any conflict or inconsistency between this section and the provisions of any other Ordinance, this section prevails over those provisions to the extent of the conflict or inconsistency.
各类印章类型与法律地位
1.各类型章对比
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2.大章(法团印章)是什么角色?
(1)大章是"正式加分项",不是"必要条件"。
(2)有签名 + 大章,最正式;只有符合规定的签名,同样有效;只有大章而没有授权签名,反而可能产生争议。效力高,适合用于股份证明书、正式契据、银行融资文件、重要担保等。
3.小章(圆章)的真正地位
(1)小章(圆章)是日常最常见的橡皮或原子圆章,很多人把它当成内地的"公章",但这是错误理解。小章不是《公司条例》规定的法定印章,单独盖小章一般不能构成公司的有效签署。
(2)实务上,银行或交易对手常要求"签名 + 小章"一起出现,是习惯与内部风险控制,而非法律规定小章本身有独立效力。
电子签署是否有效?
香港承认电子签署。《电子交易条例》(第553章)赋予电子签署与手写签名同等法律地位(在符合可靠、适当及对方同意等条件下)。大部分商业合约可以使用电子签署。但部分文件例外,例如遗嘱、某些不动产相关文件、授权书等,可能仍需传统亲笔签名。涉及政府机构时,通常要求使用认可数码证书的数码签署。
往期推荐
梦海专业 | 跨境司法协作实务心得:香港民商事判决内地认可执行办案总结
梦海动态 | 香港城市大学法律学院Dr. Christopher To(陶荣教授)、金叶大律师事务所一行到访梦海律所交流座谈
梦海喜讯|广东梦海律师事务所何栋民、陈纹封律师连任为第二十七届香港警察队员佐级协会法律顾问
